« Previous Page Table of Contents Next Page »

[Page 130]

Shuln un bote-medroshim in Kolomey

Synagogues and study-houses in Kolomey

Pages 130-142 translated by Tina Lunson
and Pages 143-156 translated by Gloria Berkenstat Freund

In my youth, before the First World War, Kolomey had – besides the great shul – another thirty shuln [synagogues] and kloyzn [small, often trade-specific synagogues] and two bote-medroshim [study houses]. In addition to those there were many minyonim [prayer quorums] in shtiblekh [prayer rooms, often Hasidic]. The majority of them were built after the year tav-khof (1660); the great shul was completely rebuilt after the conflagration of tav-kuf-pey-zayn (1827) and remodeled in the year tav-reysh-khof (1860) during the time of Rebi Tsvi zts”l [may his holy memory be for a blessing] of Rimanov. In tav-reysh-khof-hey (1865) most of the shuln and bote-medroshim burned down, along with the old pinkusim [community record books].

In the year tav-reysh-yud-giml (1853) there was a misfortune on yonkiper [Yom Kippur, the day of atonement]: during nile [the closing prayers of the day] some scoundrels spread the rumor that a fire had broken out in order to create a panic among the women in the women's section of the great synagogue, thus enabling the scoundrels to rob them of their jewelry. The women began to run in great disorder, and in the chaos 33 women and 2 children were killed. From then on there was a law against women wearing jewelry on yonkiper. In the old pinkes of the khevre kadishe [burial society] “gemiles khsodim” [loving kindnesses] is printed the lament that was composed for those very victims with the words (as it was recorded in the book zikron lroshonim [in memory of the forefathers] by Judge Khaym Tsvi Taumim z”l [of blessed memory]:

“Sun and moon darken, and the stars of the heavens do not shed light either. O, one must cry out in witness to the tremendous distress. The stern decree of utter destruction came down upon tranquil women, faithful daughters tender and delightful, and also precious and playful children on yonkiper during the time of the nile [when] suddenly a ripping voice caused the doorposts to tremble and a loud noise filled the house of God and the beseechers urgently left. Then You will ask to return their souls to the heavens; therefore Master of Mercy shelter them in the shelter of your wings forever, among the residents of the Garden of Eden in the highest heavens – there will be their proper resting place. Omeyn.”
The representatives and trustees of the great synagogue in my day were:

Yomye Marmorosh, Yoyne Kizler, Itskhok Zaydman, Mendl Fridman, Shimen Zenenzib and others. Among those who prayed there

[Page 131]

I remember Shmuel Herman, Yekheskel Holes, Moyshe Hamer, Avrom Neyder, Aleksander Shor, Shloyme Fridman, Antshl Bishel, Zalman Grinberg, and many others of the residents who did observe the mitsvos [Jewish laws] but who were for the most part not Hasidim and even were considered “modern.”

Off the corridor of the main entrance on the right and the left were another two large rooms that served as a study-house for prayer and study.

The Hasidic kloyzn were: Boyan, a handsome building built in 1893, most of the money for its construction coming from the family Heler; Vizshnits, at first together with the Atinye Hasidim; Atinye, after the split; Zshiditshov; Tshortkov, the main funds for construction given by the Tshortkov Hasidim Ayzik Sharf and my father Meshulem Fried; Kosov (in whose house, according to legend, the Bal Shem-tov zts”l stayed when he lived in Kolomey). Various Hasidim and eminent householders prayed in “Reb Itsikl's shul”, named after the Radzivil saint; regular observant Jews prayed at the Azipol and Sharigrad shuln, along with various Hasidim.

Hundreds of men and women prayed in the large and spacious “yerushalayim” [Jerusalem] shul; the old besmedresh; the new besmedresh; the shulKamionke” near the very old cemetery; the shul Siks named after the town of Siks where Rov [“rabbi”] Hilel Likhtenshteyn was rov before he came to Kolomey, where there prayed the very observant and God-fearing, Hasidim of Rov Hilel Likhtenshteyn headed by Iser Kris; they generally prayed before dawn, very early in the morning, even on shabes [sabbath] and holidays, and then studied a page of Talmud; they were almost like ascetics, puritans, and the fanatic Hasidim called them ”di trukene kroym” [those dry Karaites] or Karaites; Klebanye shuln; train shuln; Verbish shuln; Dietkovits shuln; shuln for craftsmen: tailor's shul, shoemaker's shul; the shul in the Zionist club ”beys yisroel” [house of Israel]; the minyonim in the homes of rabonim [“rabbis”]; khab'ad [Khabad Hasidism, based on the tenets khokhma, bine, khesed or knowledge, wisdom, loving kindness], harav”d, the magid [preacher], the Sohole Rebi [Hasidic charismatic rov], the Yase rebi, the Rebi ”Bakhor”, the Rov Antshl (the son-in-law of Rov Hilel) and other small minyonim on other streets.

In the Hasidic kloyzn, as also in the two bote-medroshim and in the Siks shul, young men studied by day and by night in Talmud and in the shulkhn orekh [laws for Jewish life as compiled for Ashkenazi Jews by J. Karo in the 16th century], and many of their fathers – sons of the Torah and observers of the mitsves – also sat after morning prayers and in the evening over a page of Talmud or looked up a commentary in ayn yankev [ethical and inspirational teachings of the Talmud by Rov Yankev ibn Khaviv, 15th century] or another book. On shabes and holidays there were two minyonim in almost all these houses of prayer: in the morning from 7 until 9 and from 9 until 11 or 12. During the week there were several minyonim, from before dawn until 10 o'clock.

In the kloyz of the Boyan Hasidim the family Heler held sway, the sons and the sons-in-law and grandsons of the wealthy and saintly Rov Shloyme Haleyvi Heler, who was a great-grandson of the fifth generation of the genius Rov Yomtov Lipe Heler, author of tosafos yomtov [commentaries by Yomtov]. His oldest son, the wealthy Shimshon, was a fiery Boyan Hasid. His three sons – Avrom Shmuel, Yosl and Lipe – were very dignified, Talmud scholars, prayer leaders and leaders of minyonim, and together they operated the big talis [prayer-shawl] factory that became famous all over the world.

During the First World War, in 1915, Yosl, the second son, was taken back by the Russians as a “hostage”, and perished there. The third son, Lipe, was a Talmud scholar and became the son-in-law of his uncle Sholem Robinzon, who was a son-in-law of Shloyme Heler. The younger brother of Shimshon, Mayer Heler, was also a great Hasid full of religious enthusiasm, an outstanding prayer leader and composer of nigunim [melodies without words]. He became a partner with his father-in-law Sholem Robinzon in the great enterprise “Robinzon and Heler”. His son, my boyhood friend Yekl Heler, lives in Tel Aviv. And Azriel Heler, the son-in-law of Shloyme and his five sons, prayed and studied in that same kloyz. The members of that family – according to the example of their rebi – conducted themselves aristocratically, in the elegance of their clothing and in giving charity. Thanks to that and due to their good breeding, which included great Torah scholars from many generations, they were highly esteemed and they left their mark on that very beautiful kloyz. The other Boyan Hasidim and other pious Jews who were not Hasidim attached themselves to that family, because they strove to have their children educated in that Hasidic-scholarly-wealthy atmosphere. So, for example, joined Leybush Osterzetser and his sons, who was a grandson of the genius Meshulem Halevi Ish Horovits, head of the beys din [Jewish court of law] of Stanislav, a great Talmud scholar, a fearer of heaven, although far from being Hasidic. In the end he left the kloyz because of a dispute and

[Page 133]

went over to Rov Itsikl's shul.

People sat in that Boyan shul studying throughout the whole day, and especially in the evenings. On Friday nights in the winter everyone went to the shul after dinner and spent a pleasant time dancing, singing and hearing words of Torah until late at night. I remember that once when Avrom Shmuel Heler was a half-hour late – and he was in his middle age by then – his father Shimshon shouted at him in front of all the onlookers, “You sit with the women and you chatter about nothing, and that is why you are late.” Another of the members of the Boyan kloyz was Nisn Ayzner. They called him Nisn Cabinet-maker because he was a wonderful artisan of house furniture, who was also called to the Boyan rebi's. Once, on his way back from Boyan, he met Motye Herman who was a joker, who asked him, “So, Nisn, how was the rebi's table? You are such an expert with tables…”

When there arrived a rebi who was a grandson or great-grandson of Rizshin, like, for example, the Gvozdiets rebi, the son-in-law of the Sadiger rebi who was a brother of the Boyan rebi, he would pray shabes at the Boyan kloyz.

During the time of the elections to the Austrian parliament I made a special trip from Krakow to Kolomey and spoke in several shuln in favor of the national candidate, and in the Boyan kloyz I had permission to speak from the bime on shabes, although they were opposed to Zionism. I was not allowed to set foot in the Vizshnits kloyz. One could say that the Boyan Hasidim were the aristocrats among the Kolomey Hasidim.

The Vizshnits kloyz was completely Hasidic. Frequent disputes would erupt between the Vizshnits and Atenye Hasidim even though the two rebis were brothers. Finally they split in tav resh samekh zayn [1907] and the Atenyes built their own beautiful kloyz.

People studied day and night in that kloyz as well. Among the worshipers there I remember: Aron Koen and his sons, Itsye Bretler and his sons and grandsons, Alter Finkl, Moyshe Kopler, Yehuda Ber Zaydman, a son-in-law of Iser Kris who came over from the “Siks” shul, an intellectual Atenye Hasid (his son is

[Page 134]

the writer and teacher I. A. Zaydman in Jerusalem), Mendl Shayerman, Dovid Kasvan, one of the leading Atenye Hasidim, Mendl Dikman, a son-in-law of Hirsh Ramler, Yoysef Shpits and Avrom Mayer Berish's, Liber Shaler, Zelik Sharf, Itsik Khasid, the “flogger” of the Atenye Hasidim, Efraym Mayer Menashe's, Moyshe Drimer and his son-in-law Yekhiel Rozenberg, Moyshe Mendl Zaydman, Meshulem Eyferman, his son Leybele and his son-in-law Itsye Grinberg, Hersh Kats and his sons, Vovik Rozenkrants, Moyshe Pidvisoker, Moyshe Sharf and his son Lipe, a loyal Zionist and collector for “keren kayemet” [Jewish National Fund for purchasing land in Palestine] who now lives in Jerusalem, and others.

The site for building the Zshiditshov kloyz was the gift of Elye Heger, who was also called Elye Honeymaker. His house was closely connected to the kloyz. He was also the main gabay [warden] and very strong-minded. I recall that one shabes there arrived a grandson of the Zshiditshov rebi, the son of the sainted Mendele of blessed memory, and Elye would not allow him to pray in the kloyz because he – Elye – only recognized one Zshiditshov rebi, the one who was then the head of the beys din in Zshiditshov and he was necessarily the younger one, who came every year to Kolomey, and therefore the son of the sainted Mendl Getsvongen had to go to pray in Rebi Itsikl's shul. And the saint of Doline, who stemmed from the Zshiditshov line, used to come to our town for shabes and pray at the Zshiditshov kloyz. Also a second grandson, Moyshe Aykhenshteyn, who lived in Kolomey, used to pray in Rebi Itsikl's shul because Elye Honeymaker did not recognize him either.

Pious, respectable Jews who were not Zshiditshov Hasidim also prayed in that kloyz, such as: Shmuel Horovits and his sons and sons-in-law, Fishl Etinger (his father Gershon and his brother Hirshe Volf were Zshiditshov Hasidim), Zelig Khayes and his sons Zeyde and Leybush, Fishl Heger, Itsik Herman and his son-in-law Yekl Helitsher, and others.

And still many other Zshiditshov Hasidim prayed in other shuln, in particular the shul named for Rebi Itsikl of Radzivil. Outstanding prayer leaders in the Zshiditshov kloyz were Mayer Frantsoyz [a] and Hirsh Volf Etinger.

[Page 135]

The Tshortkov kloyz was small and the number of attendees was not large. A lot of Tshortkov and Sadiger Hasidim also prayed at other shuln. The kloyz was completely destroyed by canon during World War I.

During my childhood I prayed and studied in that kloyz and my father often led from the cantor's stand on shabes, holidays and high holidays, but even before my barmitsve he had gone from the Tshortkov kloyz over to Rebi Itsikl's shul.

Of the people at the Tshortkov kloyz I remember: Ayzik Sharf, Meshulem Fried, Efraym Kopl's, Berl Dinstfeld, Hirsh Rekhter, Berl Sekhestover and his son Hershl, Leyb Esnfeld, Fayvish Mentshl, Motl Sher, the orator Rov Itskhak Veber, his brother Moyshe Veber, Henekh Shekhter, Mordkhe Nusboym, Binyumin Shekhter, Yosye Kreyttser, Gavriel Grinberg, Shloyme Grosbakh, Moyshe Sadigurski, Berl Bortn, Aron Peysakh (a son-in-law of Mayer Frantsoyz.)

I did not go to the Kosov kloyz and so I do not know who did go there. I only remember that Dovid (Dudye) Kramer, a wonderful prayer leader, was the cantor.

In that shul named for Rebi Itsikl the Radzivil Saint, there were many very respectable Jews, pious Talmud scholars, various Hasidim and proprietors. It was reckoned among the most distinguished shuln in our community. The [Jewish] judge Rov Yehoshe Heshl Zilber of blessed memory who prayed there, used to study a lesson from Talmud for children, myself included, on the winter nights. And Mordkhe Itsye – a Talmud expert and very pious, a Hasid after the brilliant and saintly Rov Avrom Dovid Butshatsher may his holy memory be for a blessing – used to teach an open commentary session every evening and on shabes before the late-afternoon prayers.

As in all the kloyzn, here too all the pious Jews sat at the third feast of shabes and sang long after the first stars had been sighted [indicating the end of the Sabbath]. Itsikl Shayke's (Fridfertig) sat at the head of the table and sang the shabes songs. Among the attendees were: Yom Tov Lipa (Lipman), Haleyvi Herman, the head of the shul, his son Motye Herman, who would inherit being head of the shul, vice-president of the community council; Shloyme Bikl-Khalfn, an anti-Hasid, a Talmud scholar, a banker; Zerakh Erlikh, his son Yeshaye, Shloyme Heler, a Boyan Hasid, Aron Shoykhet, Sender Yoel, an in-law of the Zshiditshov rebi; Itskhak Leyb Goldshteyn, Yosl Meltzer, a Tshortkov Hasid, Meshulem Simkhe Linder (Vizshnits Hasid), Hirsh

[Page 136]

Ramler, a very rich man, with his sons-in-law: Moyshe Landoy (a Sadiger Hasid and a Talmud scholar), Efroym Klarman, from Krakow, a Talmud scholar and an enlightener, very pious, a fervent Zionist; the judge Rov Yehoshe Heshl Zilber, Tshortkov Hasid, Menashe Roykhverger and his son, my friend Dr. Zerakh, attorney, Talmud scholar and pious Jew, Moyshe Aykhenshteyn, a grandson of the Saint of Zshiditshov; Moyshe Brandes, the son of a rov, Talmud scholar, enlightener, Stretin Hasid; Sholem Veber and his sons Yekhezkl (Khaskl) and Mordkhe and his son-in-lawYudl Nagelberg, Leybush Osterzetser, Talmud scholar, a grandson of the genius Rov Meshulem Horovits head of the beys din of the community of Stanislav and his sons Ruveyn, Shloyme and Nosn; Mordkhe Bikl (son of Shloyme Bikl) and his father-in-law Motl Kahana with the nickname “Ponia”, a Russian Jew, his father-in-law Simkhe Tsimels, from Brod, a Talmud scholar, and expert in Torah, Prophets and Writings, and his son-in-law Hershl Tsimels, also from Brod, Talmud scholar and enlightener; Yosl Gotlib, Atenye Hasid and his son Gershon, Yosele Brotshiner-Vahl, a distinguished scholar (who also arranged for guests to have Friday night dinner in the homes of local householders). Mordkhe Itsye's, scholar of spreader of Torah, Dovid Leyb Hofman, a scholar, a friend and the right-hand man to the preacher Itskhak Veber, Sholem Robinzon, Shmuel Fried, Zalman Shperber, Sh. Grayf and his sons Aron and Zerekh, a son of Torah and a brilliant prayer leader, Berl Vinkler, Hershl Bernshteyn from Tarnov, Gedalye Fayr a son-in-law of Aron Shoykhet, Shloyme Shrayer, Fayvish Hanoman with the nickname “Holopietnik”, a passionate Zshiditshov Hasid, a fiery prayer leader [a]; Yoel Mayer Prays, the Toah reader at the shul for decades; his son Dovid Shloyme, Efraym Hibner, Gershen Tahau and his son Itsye and others.

Motye Herman led the shul with a strong hand. I remember that one simkhes toyre [rejoicing in the Torah] at night, quite a few Jews who on holidays studied with Judge Yehoshua Hershl Zilber arrived along with the Judge, with torches and song as was the custom, late for the evening service and late for the hakofes [circuits, in which the Torah scrolls are carried around the shul]. Motye Herman was leading the service. The Jews with the Judge came in during the evening shimenesre [Eighteen Benedictions, recited standing] and were angry that they had not delayed the prayers on account of the Judge and of them. And one of them – Dovid Leyb Hofman – began to loudly sing the borekhu [introductory prayer], and broke into the shimenesre. After finishing the prayer, Motye got up on a lectern and shouted like a commandant, “Have respect!”

[Page 137]

Another episode from my youth is etched in my memory: On simkhes toyre the title of “bridegroom of the Torah” belonged to Rebi Moyshe Aykhenshteyn, a grandson of Zshiditshov rebis; and the honor of the first reading in Genesis belonged to Motye Herman. One time Rebi Moyshe was ill and his title “bridegroom of the Torah” was sold for 200 gulden to the wealthy Hirsh Ramler, who was a pious and genial Jew but really quite simple, not a student of Torah and not even a reader of holy books. He was busy day and night with his businesses. I was very chagrined at this insult to the honor of the Torah and I told the shul wardens a joke that was repeated about the genius Rov Shemen Soyfer head of the beys din of Krakow. When a similar thing had happened in his community in his time, he had remarked to his wardens, “We see today a match made in the style of the Polish Hasidim.” When asked the meaning of his remark, he translated it “The groom has not met the bride before the wedding.”

I remember another event that well illustrates the morals of those who prayed at that shul. A Jew by the name of Berl Vinkler, who loaned money for interest, made a complaint in court against the debtor Zalman Shperber, who also prayed there, because he had not repaid his loan within the terms set. One weekday he came into the shlul full of righteousness and occupied the debtor Zalman Shperber's special assigned chair. The wardens and the congregants were enraged at this ignominious act, and they made a decision: accordingly, on shabes they interrupted the service in the middle when Berl Vinkler showed up, saying that they would not pray with such a person. Since Berl Vinkler would not leave the shul, they all – led by Motye Herman – went to the besmedresh next door and continued their service there.

Most of the people who prayed at the Azipol kloyz were those who lived in that area (behind the town hall). I remember some of them. Moyshe Aynhorn, a distinguished householder and father of 14 sons and daughters, all by one mother; Yehuda Leyb Grin, a son-in-law of Yehuda Hirsh Glinert, a Talmud expert and Enlightener, an extreme anti-Hasid; Moyshe Bokhnier, a Zshiditshov Hasid, an exquisite prayer leader, Khaym Dovidl's Halbershtam, a Talmud expert and a very pious Jew, my father-in-law Moyshe Zinger may he rest in peace, Berish Hilzenrat, Moyshe Tsukerman, a scholar and a passionate prayer leader, a faithful follower and the right hand of the preacher Rov Itskhak Veber,

[Page 138]

Alter Toybish, a son-in-law of Shaul Vaysman, a scholar and enthusiastic Zionist; Shmuel Laden, Mendl Shayerman.

The Sharigrad kloyz comprised mixed Jews of every type. It was well known that every simkhes toyre disputes broke out there about the honors for leading certain prayers, for carrying the Torah in the circuits and for the Torah blessings, and the ardor for honors often led even to fisticuffs.

Of those who went there I remember Khaym (Finies) Frenkl, a Zshiditshov Hasid and fine prayer leader; Motye Bretler, the eldest son of the millionaire Yankev Bretler; Motye Peye Malke's, Hasid, Torah expert and prayer leader, Yisroel Eyferman, the father-in-law of Dr. Fishl Rotenshtraykh, the former member of the Sokhnut management in Jerusalem; Khaym Zizkind, Hirsh Kris, his son-in-law Leyb Post, Zisye Hofman and his son Dovid, Yekl Sokal, a scholar and Enlightener, Dovid Glinert, Yisroel Kantor and others.

In the ”Yerushalyim” [Jerusalem] shul there worshiped various sorts of Hasidim and regular, observant, prominent householders and many who lived in that area. On weekdays six or eight minyonim prayed there, from before dawn until noon. And flocks of orphans came to say kadish [a praise to God that is recited by mourners] at the combined afternoon-evening service. On shabes afternoons they studied a page of Talmud or commentary, and often preachers and orators spoke, visitors from other places; and the Zionists held their meetings there, where there were often religious speakers who clarified the Zionist and nationalist thinking and who spiced their speeches with many kinds of examples, commentaries from holy sources, and sayings of the sages. Of those who prayed there I remember: Yankl Beydaf, the head of the Jewish community and the town council, a passionate Vizshnits Hasid who also used to travel to Zshiditshov, exceptionally wealthy, the father-in-law of Rov Yosl Lau; the Vizshnits Rebi and the Zshiditshov Rebi, who used to come to Kolomey for shabes stayed with him.

He was a clever Jew, nimble and ebullient, a social person. But the same Hasid who on Friday night danced on the table before the rebi, as was the Vizshnits custom, was one of the most assimilated, one who danced to the humiliating tune of the Polish princes, who spoke in the name of the Hasidim against the nationalist Jews and Zionists and for those assimilated to Polish culture, in particular during the time of the elections to the Austrian parliament, to the parliament of Galicia and the council. (Aron Koen, the head of the Jewish community, a Vizshnits Hasid, wealthy,

[Page 139]

well-dressed, behaved in just the same way, although neither of them could speak a word of Polish…) His two sons, Itsye Beydaf and Leybush (a son-in-law of Shmuel Horovits); Yankl Bretler, a multi-millionaire, religious but not a Hasid, his two sons Yoyne and Mendl; his three sons-in-law Moyshe Zaydman, Moshe Breyer and Nosn Baron; Motl Breyer, Meylekh Tsvibl, Shimshen Koynits, Motl Kramer, Shaul Vaysman and his son-in-law Motl Frish, Aba Hamer, A. Slopkovitser, a son-in-law of Moyshe Zaydman, a Talmud expert and Enlightener and very pious, who dressed in modern clothes, a Zionist; A. Kristiampolier, a son-in-law of Moyshe Breyer, from Brod, a Talmud expert and an Enlightener, from a good family, very pious, dressed in modern clothes; Moyshe Rohatin, a son of the head of the beys din of Zlotshev and a son-in-law of Moyshe Breyer, a Torah scholar and champion of Enlightenment, an active Zionist and a good speaker; Yisroel Khaym Henish, a teacher of Torah, Prophets and Writings [the “old testament”] and Hebrew grammar on a high level (an uncle of the writer and journalist Mayer Henish in Tel Aviv); Moyshe Feldman and his sons Khaym and Leybush; Khaym Laks, Gedalye Biter and his sons, Itsye Hekht and his son Shmuel, Shloyme Ashkenazi, Alter Rat, Volf Faktor, Yehuda Hersh Gliner and his sons, Avrom Itsye Soykher, Itsye Heger, Avrom Elye Ramler, and others.

Rov Yankev Taumim and Rov Gedalye Shmelkish used to pray there during the week on the days when Torah is read and on the new moon.

There were a lot of people at the old besmedresh, mostly regular observant Jews and no Hasidim, and on shabes afternoons the orator Itskhak Veber of blessed memory used to preach to a large audience.

That was where the judge Rov Moyshe Yehoshue of blessed memory, the so-called “head of the yeshiva” prayed, and also his sons Alter and Khaym. Of the others I remember: Yudl Krebs, the chief warden, the wealthy Shaol Kneper, his son Alter Kneper, an in-law of Rov Gedalye Shmelkish of blessed memory, his son-in-law L. Mandel, a Talmud expert and very pious, Dovid Vayzelberg, Kopl Bekher and his sons, Yonatan Vielitshker and his son, Shloyme Vaysbakh, Moyshe Ivanier and his son Zindl and others.

On shabes parshas yitro of tav-reysh-samekh”khes [the Sabbath on which the Torah portion called Jethro is read (sometime in February) in 1908] a terrible fire broke out in the old besmedresh and 11 Torah scrolls were burned. The whole town was greatly saddened and the rabonim called for a community fast and buried the remains in the Jewish cemetery.

Many proprietors prayed at the new besmedresh. It is possible I am mistaken about the place where the preacher Itskhak Veber sermonized, and that he preached at the new besmedresh, which was near the building of the old one.

[Page 140]

In both of them, many people studied Talmud, commentaries, ayn yankev and even Torah with RaShI's commentary [acronym for Rov Shloyme Itskhaki, 11th century].

The main people at the Siks shul were: Iser Kris, vice president of the Jewish community, very pious, wealthy, a follower of Rov Hilel Likhtenshteyn and later also of Rov Gedalye Shmelkish (I recall that in the memorial speech at his funeral, Rov Gedalye Shmelkish said of the deceased, with a bitter cry, that he was a “holy Jew”) ; his son Leybush Kris, his son-in-law I. Zshenirer, his son-in-law Yehude Ber Zaydman, of the main Atenye Hasidim that later went over to the Atenye kloyz; Shmuel Shupt, A. Shoym, Mikhal Hamer, the children of Rov Hilel Likhtenshteyn, Borekh Bendit, Zalman and his sons. For many years after Rov Hilel passed on his spirit still hovered over that besmedresh, though the Hasidim and especially the Vizshnits Hasidim disparaged it.

Various people prayed at the “Talmud-Torah” shul, members of the “Talmud-Torah” (see further on) and those who lived in that neighborhood, and headed by Tomed Shoykhet, a son of Aron Shoykhet. He was a kind of recluse and holy man who rarely spoke, and on shabes he would speak only Hebrew. (It is said that he would say to his wife [in Hebrew] “Tnay li khalav yoyshev” which means “milk that has sat” [in a glass together with sour cream]; and every Friday he would go from shop to shop and collect donations for little-known poor people.

His father Aron Shoykhet was the founder and agent of the “Talmud-Torah”, a large religious school for poor students, and devoted himself to it well into his advanced years.

The Kamionk shul, on Kamionk Street near the very old cemetery, held mostly people who lived in that vicinity, among them some Hasidim. I only remember a few of them: Alter Taykher and his son Shimen Taykher, owner of a famous Hebrew press, Hirsh Rat, the eminent teacher (see further on), Moyshe Tindl, Yekl Tindl, Hirsh Leyb Rat, his sons Shimen and Moyshe, Yoyne Zager, owner of a talis factory, Yoyne Hibner. Housed in that building was the best school of that time, with the teacher Hirsh Rat.

In the Zionists' shul, ”beys yisroel”, were the leaders of that movement and many of its members. I can recall a few of them: Yehoshue Fadenhekht, the president of the shul and of the club ”beys yisroel”, the headmaster, a Talmud scholar, Enlightener, pious, a passionate Zionist; Leybl Toybish, the son of the head of the beys din of Atenye, a Talmud scholar, Enlightener

[Page 141]

The wooden shul in Petshinizshin
The wooden shul in Yablonov


The Talmud Torah

[Page 142]

a popular speaker and a wonderful interpreter of Zionist thought, Leybush Yeger, Talmud expert, Enlightener, I. Mayer, the grandfather of a professor of archeology at Jerusalem University; A. Slopkovitser, Motl Berger (a freethinker and yet he never missed coming to pray on shabes and holidays), Mayer Henish, Avigdor Khaym Shternberg, well-known prayer leader, Moyshe Laks, a son of Khaym Laks, a Talmud expert and good speaker, editor of a Zionist weekly newspaper in Yiddish in which I published articles during the time of the elections to parliament.

The other shuln and minyonim in the streets that were farther from the center of town and in the suburbs were filled with the people who lived in those areas, mostly craftsmen and small merchants and a few Hasidim and Talmud scholars. The locals of the suburb of Verbish prayed at the minyon at Rov Antshl's (a son-in-law of Rov Hilel Likhtenshteyn); and among them was my wife's grandfather Hirsh Vagenberg, a Vizshnits Hasid, a Torah scholar and giver of charity, his wife Bobole was active in the community with aid and charity.

During the time of my youth the community numbered three thousand families, about twenty thousand souls. Upwards of eighty percent of the Kolomey Jews were religious, observers of all the mitsvos [the Ten Commandments plus 613 other laws and rules of Jewish life], half of these Hasidim of various rebeyim. Among them were Talmud scholars, completely reverent Jews, and also Enlighteners and many pious householders. Of those about ten percent were “modern”, having given up shtraymlekh [wide-brimmed fur hats] to wear top hats on shabes and holidays, and sending their children to modern, non-religious schools and marrying their daughters to doctors who were freethinkers, far from Jewish tradition, although they themselves were still religious. And less than ten percent, some trade-intellectuals, attorneys, doctors, state agents, teachers and a few rich people, desecrated the shabes and only came to shul on the Jewish new year and yonkiper.

And yet they stood at the top of the community and they represented the Jewish interest in the town hall, as was usual in Galicia at the time, and the majority of the religious Jews had to be satisfied with providing for their own needs in matters of ritual slaughter, mikve [ritual baths] and so on.

All the businesses were in Jewish hands, and on shabosim un yontoyvim not one business was open except for the three apothecaries, two of which were Christian-owned. Even among the non-religious merchants no one would dare to open on shabes, and it was not worthwhile because there would not be any customers because even the non-Jews knew that everything was closed on shabes. When Maks Feldman, the youngest son of Moyshe Feldman, opened his drugstore on shabes with the explanation that it was under the regulations of an apothecary, the town went off its wheels.

The character of the community was pious. I do not know how Kolomey seemed in the nineteen-twenties and -thirties because I lived in Vienna in those years, and the ties that bound me to my hometown were broken.

[Page 143]

The Best Bale-tfile [1] Tof Our Kehile

The synagogues, kloyzn [houses of prayer, often specific to an occupation or Hasidic sect], Boti Medroshim [houses of study], shulekhn [prayer houses] and the many minyonim [quorum of 10 men necessary for prayer] were always full of worshippers and on the Shabbosim [Sabbaths] and yontovim [holidays] bale-tfile, bale-menagnim [those who are talented musicians], Hasidim and folksy sheliekhi-tsiber [leaders of communal prayer] would [lead the] prayers without pay.

The khazonim [cantors] were paid in the large synagogue, but they were never the best because the wages were small. But well-known khazonim often came from outside on one or two Shabbosim and appeared at the large synagogue.

Of the bale-tfile I remember the best known of them: Zhiditshov [Zhydachiv] liturgical tradition: Reb Meir Francoiz, who was the best of them; Reb Hirsh Volf Etinger; Reb Chaim Frenkel; Reb Moshe Bochnier; Reb Itzikl Sheikes-Fridfertig; Reb Dovid Haker; Feyvish Khanaman. There surely were others whom I did not know or whom I can no longer remember. In the Sadigurer liturgical tradition: my father, Reb Shimeon Rat, of blessed memory, a Chartkover Hasid, was a talented musician, had a very pleasant voice, was a good leader. Over the course of 45 years, he prayed on Shabbosim and holidays and on the Days of Awe as the bal-musaf [leader of the recitation of the additional prayers] and Neilah [concluding Yom Kippur prayer] at the Chartkover Hasidim's kloyz and then at the synagogue named Di Itzikl [the Itzikl] and he would evoke pleasure and delight

[Page 144]

in his listeners. Motzei Yom Kippur [evening right after Yom Kippur] the representatives of the synagogue came home to my father to express their thanks and respect to him and then to spend time singing and dancing. The magid [preacher], Reb Yitzhak Weber, of blessed memory, was a wonderful prayer leader; he composed melodies that were also sung by other bale-tfile: his student and admirer, Reb Moshe Cukerman; Reb Motel Szer; Reb Meir Heler; Reb Avraham Shmuel Heler; Reb Zorekh Grajf; Reb Dovid Kramer; Reb Ruvin Osterzetser.

Those of the Vizhnitz-Otinya [Otyniya] liturgical tradition: Reb Menashe's Efroim Meir (Sucher); Reb Vovik Rozenkranc; Reb Liber Szaler; Reb Moshe Pirvisoker. All sang their prayers with Hasidic melodies that they took from the well-known khazonim at the rabbinical courts. In this area no one was isolated and superior; everyone benefited from all Hasidic melodies and spread all of their melodies. In the kloyzn were singers who would travel to rebbes and there learn melodies by ear; among them also were those who transcribed the notes and brought the new melodies to the city, where they spread immediately to all kloyzn through the prayer leaders. I remember that at the Vizhnitz-Otinya kloyz there was a fervid Hasid, very musical, although he had a weak voice. He was named Reb Berish's Avraham Meir and he would go to the Otinyer Rebbe twice a month for Shabbosim. There was a famous khazan there who would compose Hasidic songs sung at the Shabbos table. He was named Reb Yisroel Sztajnfert. Reb Yisroel was born in 5612-1852 in Berdichev. He was a choirboy with Avraham Goldfaden with Reb Yeruham ha-Koton [the little one] at the Berdichev Choral Synagogue. He was khazan in the court of the Sadigurer Rebbe, then at the court of the Rebbe, Reb Shmuel Aba Haner from Horodenka, may the memory of a righteous man be blessed, and finally in Otinya for many years. From 1914 until 1930 he was in America and then returned to Stanislav, where the Otinyer Rebbe lived after the First World War.

His melodies and Shabbos songs were sung by thousands of Hasidim in all of eastern Galicia. Reb Berish's Avraham Meir would always bring new melodies and sing them for other prayer leaders and thus they spread to all of the kloyzn and synagogues, not only during the prayers, but also in the mornings and nights; they would sing the various Hasidic melodies at the holidays and at every celebration.

[Page 145]

Scholars, Learned Men and Followers of the Enlightenment in Kolomea

In general, we cannot say that Kolomea was a city of pure learned men and followers of the Enlightenment as, for example, Brod, Tarnopol or Buczacz [Buchach]. The majority of its residents were businessmen who barely knew Khumish [Five Books of Moses] with Rashi [commentary], a chapter of Mishnayos [Oral Torah], Ein-Yakov [inspirational and ethical teachings of the Talmud], and such people were not considered as “scholars” at that time. Among the Hasidim, too, were simple men of the people, honest but not learned men. In contrast, I in my youth knew artisans, tailors, cabinetmakers, locksmiths, bakers, typesetters, who were scholars, philanthropists, hospitable men and they were respected in the city. However, there also were a number of scholars and learned men and even more scholars who had a knowledge acquired in childhood and as adults studied a page of Gemora [commentaries] in the evening and on Shabbosim. Understand that I remember only a few names from my youth, but in that era there were scholars, learned men and followers of the Enlightenment.

And these are the scholars who I knew in my youth: mentor and teacher, Reb Dovidl Taumim, of blessed memory, the son-in-law of the Rabbi Reb Yakov Taumim, of blessed memory, the head of the Beis Din [religious court] of our community, of blessed memory, and the son of the Rabbi, Reb Moshe Taumim, and the president of the Beis Din of our community; Reb Fishl Etinger, the son of Reb Gershon, to whom the religious teachers would bring the children [they taught] on Shabbosim to be quizzed; Reb Alter Finkel, Reb Josele Brodtshiner (Vahl); Reb Avrahamle Sohler; Reb Khaskl Icik, who also was a follower of the Enlightenment and philosopher, Reb Chaim Dovidl's Halbershtam. I also heard about the learning of Reb Shlomo Bikel (Khalfan [money changer]), but he belonged to a previous generation and I did not know him.

And these were the learned men who I knew in my youth: Reb Moshele Eichensztajn, a grandson of the Zhiditshover Rebbe; Reb Itmar Shoykhet [ritual slaughterer]; Reb Meshulem Frier; Reb Mikhl Braver, a Zhiditshover Hasid who authored books about the Zhiditshover righteous men, a follower of the Enlightenment, the father of an educated geographer and well-known writer, Dr. A. Y. Braver in Jerusalem and of his brother, the teacher in Haifa; Reb Moshe Brandes, a son of a rabbi; Reb Moshe Shternhel (a son of Rosi Shternhel); Reb Efroim Klarman; Reb Feywl Francoz (a son of Reb Meir), Reb Leibush Osterzetser; Reb Leibush Horovitz (also secularly educated); Reb Moshe Landau; Reb Fishl Shorf; Reb Avraham Sofer; his son Berl Sofer (an exceptional student and the right hand of the Rabbi, Reb

[Page 146]

Yakov Taumim, of blessed memory); Reb Lipa Heler; Reb Leibl Mandel (a son-in-law of Reb Shaul Kneper); Reb Leibl Eiferman; Reb Mordka Nusbaum; Reb Henekh Shechter; Reb Itsie Grinberg; Reb Mendl Dikman; Reb Hirsh Rechter; Reb Berl Distenfeld; Reb Tsimel's Shimkha; Reb Tsimel's Hershl; Reb Dovid Leib Hofman, Reb Menashe's Efroim Meir; Reb Mordka Itsie, and, understand, the religious teachers about whom I will particularly dwell in the next chapter.

To the learned men also belonged: Yehuda Ber Zajdman; Reb Avraham Shmuel Heler; Reb Yehosha Fadenhecht (also a follower of the Enlightenment); Reb Leibl Taubish (also a follower of the Enlightenment); Reb Leibush Jener (also a follower of the Enlightenment); Reb Berl Borten; Reb Y. Slopkowicer (also a follower of the Enlightenment); Reb. A. Kristiampoler (also a follower of the Enlightenment); Reb Moshe Cukerman; Reb Feyvish Mentshl (emigrated to America), Reb Moshe Rohatin (also a follower of the Enlightenment), Reb Ruvin Osterzetser, a son of Leibush and a son-in-law of Reb Alter Finkel; his son was the educated Dr. Yisroel Osterzetser, who was a lecturer at the Institute for Jewish Scholarship in Warsaw; Reb Shlomo Osterzetser; Reb Hershl Rozenbaum (the father of Dr. Elihu Rozenbaum-Mruz, of blessed memory, leader of the Department of Education in the municipality of Tel Aviv); Reb Itsie Zajdman, a dear student and admirer of the above-mentioned Reb Khaskl Itsik; Reb Dovidl Khahn (also secularly educated), a son of Reb Ahron Khahn, his brother Eliezer; Reb Zelig Szarf; Reb Shmuel Bretler; my father, Reb Shimeon Rat, of blessed memory; Reb Yehosha Leib Grin; Peya Malka's Reb Motie; Reb Kopl's Efroim; Reb Yosl Melcer; the sons of Reb Itsik Lieb Goldsztajn: Motele, Berele, Yisroel, all followers of the Enlightenment; Reb Itsie Bikel (a grandson of Reb Shlomo Bikel); Reb Antshl Wanenberg; Reb Leibush Kris, Dr. Zorech Rojchwerner; Reb Kalman Wajc (also a follower of the Enlightment).

Characteristic of the relationship of the city population to the rabbis and learned men is the fact that the two first deputies to the Austrian parliament who were elected in Kolomea were not only Jews, but also rabbis: the Rabbi and Gaon [genius] Reb Shimeon Sofer, of blessed memory, head of the Beis Din of Krakow (the son of the Gaon, the Mikhtav Sofer [book of responsa – as is customary, he is known by the name of his most famous book], of blessed memory), the Rabbi, Dr. Josef Bloch, of blessed memory, rabbi in Vienna and editor of the Viennese newspaper, Estreikhishe Vokhenshrift [Austrian Weekly]. In 1907, the Zionists also entered the candidacy of Dr. Yehosha Thon, rabbi in Krakow.

Even the Hasidim, who were more drawn to Hasidic religious ecstasy than to learning, which in their eyes was the status of the rebbe, the righteous man was a thousand times higher than a rabbi and head of a rabbinical court, even when he was a rabbi of all of the members of the diaspora, they were proud that their rebbe was a Torah giant and

[Page 147]

the rebbes were: Reb Yisroel from Chartkov; Reb Yisroel from Vizhnitz and his brother the rebbe from Otinya; the rabbi-rebbe from Zhiditshov Reb Meshulem of Zolynia-Nadvorna – was a great scholar in open and in secret and also one of the rabbis considered as a Torah giant.

Great respect was given in the synagogues and kloyzn to the learned men because there was great respect for learning in our community.


Melamdim [religious school teachers] and Khedorim [religious primary schools] in Kolomea

During my childhood and youth, at least 90 percent of the Jewish children in the city studied in a kheder and the majority of them studied for the entire day, particularly during the winter evenings. Only a third of them studied in the state public school in the morning and in the kheder in the afternoon. Approximately 20 percent of the young people, aged from 10 to 18, studied at the gymnazie [secondary school] and a few percent continued to study until age 14 in the burger-schule [modern secondary school]. The rest studied in kheder and the young men at the kloyzn.

The melamdim whom I remember from childhood and my young years were: for the youngest children: Reb Leibush, Reb Khaskl, Reb Yekl Kreps. In these khederim, the youngest children studied Hebrew, prayers and Khumush [the Torah] from three to six years of age. Reaching the age of six or seven, they would move to the Gemore-Melamid [teacher of commentaries]. And these were the best teachers of that time:

Reb Hirsh Rat, whose kheder at Kamionker Street near the synagogue with the same name was the best in prayer books and teaching methods; Reb Moshe Altshteter; Reb Shmuel Hirsh; Reb Vovik Rozenkranc; Reb Shlomo Mordekhai; Reb Yosi Kopler, the so-called Buczaczer [Buchacher] Melamid; Reb Leibush Horodenker; Reb Chaim Flach; Reb Yosele Brotshiner-Vahl; Reb Avrahamel Sohler; Reb M. Kohn, called the Kalisher Melamid, was considered a “modern one,” and he mainly taught the last two parts of Tanakh [the Torah, Prophets and Writings] and Hebrew grammar; as well as Reb Yisroel Chaim Henish (the father and teacher of Reb Meir Henish, the writer and journalist in Tel Aviv).

The teacher Z. Fiszbach, the Chartkover Melamid, was the teacher of Hebrew and Tanakh at the Baron Hirsh School and taught a “modern” Hebrew in courses for adults. The well-rounded scholar and philosopher, the teacher, Reb Khaskl Itsik, only taught a few adult young men. The pious suspected him of an apikorses [heresy] and the Vizhnitzer and Boyaner Hasidim

[Page 148]

bitterly persecuted him. I remember: he died during Shavous and the preacher, Reb Yitzhak Weber, took part in the funeral, and returning, Reb Leibush Osterzetser (who was not a Hasid) opposed him and reproached him bitterly for giving respect to an apikoyres [heretic] who had, ostensibly, caused many people to sin.

I studied with six of the teachers mentioned from my first year to my Bar Mitzvah. And then I began to study - only in the evening – with Reb Dovidl Taumim, with the preacher, Reb Yitzhak Weber, the Rabbi, Reb Yakov Taumim and with the religious judge, Reb Heshl Zilber.

There were other good religious teachers at the Talmud Torah [primary religious school for the children of the poor] where approximately 300 poor children and boys studied. But there also were several khedorim – on a mediocre level – where there was a lack of methods [of teaching], equipment, assistant teachers, and the fathers would often transfer [their children] to another kheder.


Hasidus in Kolomea

There was no Hasidic rebbe in our city whose followers would flock to him from other communities. But over the course of time, three rebbes whose influence in the city was negligible settled there. No one came to join them from outside [the city] to add to their small number of followers.

One was the Sohler Rebbe, who moved to Kolomea from Sohel. He was a scholar and Kabbalist, a prominent man with a distinct liturgical tradition in the prayers and a singer of Shabbos melodies; he was beloved by everyone. He was more devoted to learning than to ritual bathhouses and religious ecstasy. He did not talk at excessive length during prayers and did not host tishn [gatherings held by a rebbe for his followers at which he presents his teachings].

His few friends and the Hasidim who prayed with him provided his meager income. Women would also come to him with gifts. We lived as his neighbor and I would often go to him to pray on Friday nights. Twice I was at Seders in [his house] that would last until the middle of the night, singing Shabbos melodies. Many like me came to witness his Seder after the Seder at home had ended. His older brother was the rebbe in Tysmenic [Tysmenytsya] and they arranged a marriage between them: the daughter of the Sohler married the son of the Tysmenicer.

[Page 149]

The second one was the Jaser [Iasi] Rebbe, old and weak, almost blind. He moved from Romania to Kolomea in his old age. A small number prayed with him and it was difficult for him to support his family. The third was the Rebbe-Bukher [young man]. He was a grandson of the righteous man, Reb Mordkale Nodverner. While still a young man, an orphan of 17, he would come to our city for Shabbos and stay here with Reb Leib Zegenreich, a Hasid of the righteous man, Reb Mordkale, and he would host a tish in the rabbinical manner. During my childhood, I attended such a tish twice and I smiled. After a certain time, when he got married, he settled in our town and followers from the “common people” concentrated around him. But his behavior, his speech and his appearances in public created little respect for his rabbinical authority. The avowed Hasidim of all sorts in other cities opposed him and even scorned him. I learned later when he was living on Klebania Street that he was not engaged in Torah [study] and not in devekut [dedication to a goal] – except for the 310 ritual immersions in the mikvah [ritual bath], about which he was a great expert… And he was also involved in gossip and cheap jokes with idlers. And I was little impressed by his “wisdom” and I could not be a partner to the admiration with which our landsman [person from the same town], the writer Dr. Shlomo Bikel, in his book, A Shtot mit Yidn [A City of Jews] related to Rebbe-Bukher. Although I also heard about the readiness of the Rebbe-Bukher to help the needy.

However, of the unique qualities of the other rebbes, among them his grandfather, Reb Mordkale, and his father, the righteous man, Reb Meshulem Cziliner, I did not see even a trace of those in him.

Consequently, there was no proper rebbe's “court” in Kolomea. However, Kolomea was a city of Hasidim who were connected to great rabbinical courts with their Admoyrim [acronym of our leader, teacher and master], sons of historical dynasties in the Hasidic world, and chiefly: Boyan, Chartkhov, Viznitz, Otinya, Sadigure, Kosov, Zhiditshov. There also were individual Hasidim who would travel to Nodverne, to Belz, Husiatyn, Stratyn, Kopyczynce. The tzadikim [righteous men] of the Riziszner Dynasty, of the Frydman family, of Chartkhov, Sadigure, Boyan, Husiatyn, Bohush [Buhu?i, Romania] would not travel anywhere and the Hasidim would go to their rebbes for Shabbosim, holidays and the Days of Awe.

[Page 150]

They would remain alone with their rebbe in prayer, at the tishn [literally “tables” – meals eaten with the rebbe] and in giving gifts and kvitlekh [notes to a rebbe requesting a blessing].

In contrast, the other righteous men came to Kolomea once a year for a Shabbos and stayed a week, several for even two weeks. And then the Hasidim from Kolomea and from the surrounding area came to seek support under the sacred wing of their rebbe. Hundreds of people would push into the large synagogue or into the kloyz during the rebbe's praying, where the rebbe himself would pray at the pulpit and talk at length until two or three o'clock in the afternoon, as well as at the tishn Friday night and Shabbos, and during the weekdays they streamed to him to see him and have the merit of receiving his blessing that the requests that were in the kvitl would come true.

The tzadik [righteous man] of Kopitshinits [Kopychyntsi], who did not have a kloyz in our city and also not a lot of Hasidim, but did have a reputation for performing “miracles,” had visits from literally thousands of Jews who ran to him with gifts of money and kvitlekh. I remember that in his inn in the house of his Hasid, Reb Hirsch Bloch, all of the windowpanes and furniture were broken and the police had to restore order at the entrance [because] the crush was so great. A year later, his Hasidim rented a large apartment with a large room and the rebbe then spent two weeks in our city, but the thousands had decreased then to only hundreds.

When the tzadik of Vizhnitz, Reb Yisroel Hager, would come, his principal Hasid, the rich man and landowner, Reb Itsia Bremler, would bring the rebbe in his carriage hitched with eight horses and he, Reb Itsia Bremler, personally was the “coachman.”

There were two tishn on Friday nights. At the first, the rebbe sang Sholem Aleikhem [Peace upon You], Kidush [blessing over wine] and words of Torah, seasoned with incomprehensible talk about Kabbalah and gematria [assigning numerical value to letters of the alphabet, words, etc.] and the Hasidim would present or offer wine and the gabbai [manager of synagogue affairs], if I am not mistaken, even the rebbe himself would call out everyone by name. At the second tish, they would sing and dance together, the rebbe with the

[Page 151]

Hasidim, because the Vizhnitzer Rebbe was very folksy and the Hasidim called him Baal Ahavas Yisroel [devoted to the Jewish people].

His brother, the Otiner Rebbe, a son-in-law of the Buhusher [Buhu?i, Romania] Tzadik, from the [Ruzhiner court, was influenced by the Ruzhiner “royal” custom. He was measured, withdrawn from the people. And the tradition, that is, the particular motif in the prayer was more lyrical, quieter and restrained than the quick, hurrying and shouting tradition of his Vizhnitzer brother.

Both were great scholars. Their younger brothers – the rebbes from Horodenka, Zalishchyky, Seret, Storozhynets – would also come to our city and although they did not have their own designated Hasidim, the Vizhnitzer and Otiner Hasidim would also come to them because all of them were the sons of the previous Vizhnitzer Tzadik, Reb Borukh, may the memory of the righteous man be blessed. The son of the founder of the dynasty, Reb Mendele, may the memory of the righteous man be blessed, author of the book, Tzemakh Tzadik [Religious Scion], was the son of the tzadik, Reb Chaim, may the memory of the righteous man be blessed, the author of the book, Toras Chaim [Theory of Life]. The Kosover Rebbe also would come to us. He would behave modestly, did not talk excessively during his praying and at his tishn. His Hasidim were not many and they did not react to their rebbe with the same enthusiasm and religious ecstasy as the Vizhnitzer, Boyaner and Otiner Hasidim.

There were conflicts among the Vizhnitzer and Kosover Hasidim over the course of years. When one of the two rebbes designated a shoykhet [ritual slaughterer] or intervened for him, the other rejected him and the conflicts in the city grew and this despite the fact that both, as already mentioned above, were grandsons of the Tzadik Reb Chaim Kosover, may the memory of the righteous man be blessed.

The Vizhnitzer and Otiner Hasidim made fun of the Kosover Rebbe, who would start praying early and finish the Shabbos praying by 10 or 11 o'clock.

The watchword: “In Zhiditshov a hellish fire burns” in the time of the righteous men, Reb Tzvi (a grandson of the Baal Tosefet Yom-Tov [Yom-Tov Lipmann Heller], father-in-law of Arteres Tzvi [the crown of Tzvi – Tzvi Hirsch of Zhiditshov], [author of] Beis Yisroel [House of Israel] and Sur Mei'ra Ve'Asei Tov [Refrain from Evil and Do Good] and Pri Kodesh Hilulim [Holy Praises] and his brother's son, Reb Ayzykl, may the memory of the righteous man be blessed – [only] flickered in the time of their grandsons, who were only epigones [less distinguished imitators] of their grandfathers.

The liturgical tradition, the motifs of the prayers of the young rebbes and, even more, of the proclaimed bale-tefile, as for example: Reb Meir Francaz, Reb Chaim Frenkel, Reb Hirsh Wolf Eminger, Reb Feywish Hanam, Reb Itsikl

[Page 152]

Shajkes, Reb Moshe Bochner and others – were really ardent, fascinating and distinguished as in the time of the first Zhiditshover Tzadikim, but the “grandsons” as rebbes did not reach the ankles of their ancient grandfathers in their influence over the Hasidim and they did not have the same appeal or respect and reverence on the part of the Hasidim as the former did. When the rabbi from Zhiditshov or the rebbe from Dolyna arrived in Kolomea for a Shabbos, only tens of the devoted Hasidim sat at the tishn and the impression in the city was not the same as during a visit from the Vizhnitzer, Otiner, Kopitshinitser or even of the Kosover.

The Nadvorner Hasidim did not have their own kloyz because their number was not large and especially after the death of their rebbe, the holy Reb Mordkale, may the memory of the righteous man be blessed. But several of them who were devoted to the rebbe remained devoted to their grandsons. Reb Leib Zenenreich, a respected Jew, a learned man and communal man, stood at their head. During my childhood, we lived as neighbors with him and every time a grandson of the Rebbe, Reb Mordkale Nodverner stayed with him, I would go there to pray and to the tish.

The Tzadik Reb Mordkale had a son-in-law who was named Reb Meshulem. He was not from a branch of a rabbinical line nor from any “dynasty,” but was only descended from a rabbinical family. In his youth he was a child prodigy and an exceptional student of the gaon [genius] Reb Meshulem Horovitz, head of the beis-din in Stanislav. After he married the daughter of Reb Mordkale, the Nodverner Rebbe and spent several years in his house, he devoted himself completely to being a nister [hidden holy man or hermit] and to religious ecstasy and prayers and ritual immersion and went so far that his faither-in-law, the Tzadik, who was known as being excessive in prayers until the afternoon and whose voice of supplication every day reached the distant land, once said of him – as his Hasidim said – “He exceeds me in his obsession…”

Reb Meshulem would travel to the old Chartkover Rebbe, Reb Dovid Moshe, may the memory of the righteous man be blessed, the son of the Riziszner Rebbe. When he felt that he had reached the level of a tzadik, he asked the Chartkover Rebbe if he was suitable and worthy to take kvitlekh from his followers and the Chartkover Rebbe gave him ordination to do so. He settled in Chrzanów near Krakow and then in Zielin and then in another place and was well-known under the name the Zeliner

[Page 153]

Rebbe and by the masses with the name Der Rebbe Kvitsher [the shouting rebbe] because despite the mortifications and fasts of this thin and short man, his noise and shouting while praying literally deafened and upset the listener.

In my childhood I was present at his praying in the house of Reb Leib Zegenreich. He prayed alone in a secluded room and only came to the worshippers for Kdushe [the exaltation of God's holiness during group prayer] and when the Torah scrolls were taken out. His noise and force and his unnatural gestures are indescribable. When reciting Barukh Shamiya [Blessed is the Name], he climbed onto a chair and from there, he – literally – jumped onto a bench and then back and forth with a heartrending cry and then he fell with his face to the ground (on Shabbos!!!) and cried for several minutes. Then, when his Hasidim finished praying in the afternoon, alone in a room he began with Borekh Sheomer [beginning of a morning prayer] and continued until six o'clock at night. Many passersby remained standing outside and shuddered at his high shouting. At a time when the entire city was celebrating the third Shabbos meal, the rebbe made Kiddush [prayer over wine] for the second Shabbos meal and sang Asader l'Sudoso b'Tzafra d'Shabata [I shall offer praise at the Sabbath morning meal]. Then he said the Minkhah [afternoon] prayers, celebrated the third meal and then very late he recited the Maariv [evening] prayers and made Havdalah [the concluding Sabbath prayers].

As was the custom of the Noverdner, he would also remain for another Shabbos. And chance provided that this second Shabbos fell on erev-Tish b'Av [the eve of the fast day commemorating the destruction of the temples in Jerusalem], a nitkhe [a fast that is postponed because it occurs on a Friday or Saturday]. We all were curious as to how the rebbe would conduct himself when he had to fast and had to prepare to be a mourner on Tish b'Av. To our wonder, he then ended his praying at three o'clock and at around six o'clock he celebrated the last meal before fasting. I was with him a second time after a number of years and, even then, already old and weak, his shouting and enthusiasm had not weakened.

As I asked Reb Leib Zegenreich in my childish naivete why the rebbe jumped and shouted so, the Hasid answered me: “Go on, try and take a burning coal in your hand, you will see that you will also shout, cry and jump like he does. When the rebbe prays, his body and soul is wrapped in burning fire, a flame, a holy fire, and therefore, he acts like this.” I

[Page 154]

will never forget this sublime explanation from the Hasid, Reb Leib. On balance we can say that Kolomea was more Hasidic than other nearby cities, as for example, Stanislav or Czernowitz [Chernivtsi]. And yet the city was not ruled by any religious-Hasidic fanaticism in regard to the non-religious and even in regard to the non-observant. And regarding the national-Zionist movement, many of the pious who were infected by the ideas of the Enlightenment were simply Zionists or members of the Mizrakhi [religious Zionists] and only individual fanatics from the Vizhnitzer or Boyaner Hasidim would sometimes appear against the Zionists. Patience, mutual tolerance reigned between both sides, the pious and the intelligentsia. No sharp opposition arose as in western Galicia.

This all was in Austrian Kolomea before the First World War. But in Polish Kolomea after the war and until its destruction, the situation changed. As soon as Agudas Yisroel [Union of Israel – Orthodox opponents of Zionism] was founded, its leaders and spokesmen, with Reb Yosl Lau at the head, immediately began a vigorous campaign against the nationalists and Zionists. On one side, the Agudah [Agudas Yisroel] movement grew in all areas of politics and not only in religious life. And on the other side, a new generation grew up of hundreds of young people who studied in the state elementary and middle schools in place of in the kheder [religious school], students and intellectuals, enlightened in their thinking and in their conduct, the majority enthusiastic Zionists, some socialists, and thus the population split into two opposing directions, into two opposing camps. The idyll that had reigned in the kehile at the time of my childhood and youth disappeared, not for the benefit of religion and not for the benefit of the people.

And then came the horrible catastrophe of the genocide by the Germans and their local helpers from among the Poles and the Ukrainians who did not make a distinction between the two camps. All of the Jews in the city met the same fate. And our dear community, the large and important Jewish city, was erased from the earth. Almost all of its dear sons were slaughtered by the Nazi Satans. The few survivors were widely scattered to all the corners of the earth. An end came to

[Page 155]

to this dear community. Only earth and dust saturated with blood and ash remained of it.


The Talmud Torah named Tamkhim d'Oiraisoh [Supporters of Torah] in Kolomea

Founded in 5620-1860 at the initiative of the brilliant rabbi, Reb Tzvi Elimelikh of Dynow: at the time of my childhood Reb Ahron Shoykhet, of blessed memory stood at its head and at the time its situation was humble. The teachers received a small wage and it was not punctually paid. The supervision was inadequate. However, in the years 5664-5674 [1914-1924] it was reorganized and 300 children learned there with good teachers and a number of the subjects were dedicated to worldly education. Committee members of the leadership were: Messrs. Alter Kneper, Avraham Shmuel Heler, Mikhl Hamer, Hirsh Bolch, Chaim Sholem Shoykhet, Yehuda Ber Zaydman. They restored the building and brought in a regimen as in one of the standard schools. There also was a synagogue in the same building, as already mentioned in an earlier chapter.


Jewish Printing Shops in Kolomea

For 200 years, there were Jewish printing shop in Kolomea, where not only sidurmim [prayer books] and makhzorim [holiday prayer books were printed], but also books of Tanakh [Torah, Prophets and Writings], gemores [commentaries], books of interpretations and scholarship. At the time of my youth, the owner of the large Jewish printing shop was Reb. Alter Teycher and his son, Shmuel.


Beis-haKhoylem [hospital], Bikur Khoylem [Society to Visit the Sick], and an Old Age Home

In 5614-1854 two philanthropic institutions were founded from contributions: the hospital and the Society to Visit the Sick and in 5658-1898, at the 50th anniversary of the reign of the Austrian Kaiser, Franz Josef I, the old age home was founded and in it also a synagogue. The rich man, Reb Yakov Bretler, donated 20,000 crowns for the building and the kehile [organized Jewish community] supported the mentioned institution from the communal treasury. The Kolomea kehile also supported important philanthropic institutions this way.

[Page 156]


The cemetery at Kaminker Street is the oldest, from 300 years ago, and there lie rabbis, great scholars and tzadikim, not only Kolomea residents, but also those from other places. In 5543-1783, this cemetery was closed and another field was designated as a cemetery, in the south of the city and it served as a cemetery for more than 100 years and rabbis and tzadikim are also buried there.

In 5650-1890, a new cemetery was [consecrated] in Vincentovka. Great rabbis from eastern Galicia were present at the ceremony at that time: the brilliant rabbi, Reb Arya Leibush Ish Hurvits, of blessed memory, the head of the religious court in Stryi and then Stanislav, author of responsa, Hare Besamim [Mountain of Spices]; the brilliant rabbi, Reb Avrahm Manakhem Shteinberg, of blessed memory, the head of the religious court in Sniatyn and later Brod; the brilliant rabbi, Reb Yehuda Leibush Landau, of blessed memory, the head of the religious court in Sadigura, author of Yad Yehuda [Hand of Yehuda]; the brilliant rabbi, Reb Yosef Shmuel Gelernter, of blessed memory, the head of the religious court in Kitev; the brilliant rabbi, Reb Yakov Taumim, of blessed memory, the head of the religious court in Kolomea.



My task was to bring to life the kehile in memorium only from one standpoint: the Jewish-religious Kolomea. However, it was difficult for me to fulfill all that I had undertaken because in the half-jubilee anniversary of the [25] years that I had lived in Vienna – from 1914 to 1939 – I had no contact with my birth city after my parents left the city at the outbreak of the war in 1914 and settled in Grosswardein (Oradea Mare). Therefore, I could only speak of and describe religious Kolomea until the end of the era before the First World War.

May my modest contribution in this memorial book be a kaddish yatom [memorial prayer recited at a parent's grave] for the neshama aliyah [may the soul go to a higher place in paradise] of the mother kehile in which I was raised, where the bones of my grandfathers of generations rest, a mourner and alone with sadness and grief for the dear ones who perished, who died el kiddush haShem ha-ummah [in sanctification of the Name and the nation].

Yitgadal v'yitkadash sh'mei raba [Glorified and sanctified be God's great name; the beginning of the mourner's prayer].

Translator's footnote:

  1. Bale-tfile are those who lead communal prayers. A kehile is an organized Jewish community. Return

Original Footnotes

  1. See Shloyme Bikl's chapters about Mayer Frantsoyz in A shtot fun yidn [A town of Jews], New York, 1943 Return
  2. See about him in Shloyme Bikl's A shtot mit yidn [A town of Jews], New York 1943 Return

[Page 157]

A List of Books

Books that were published in Kolomyya between the years 1880-1930
Assembled from the Bibliographer A. Yaari (Jerusalem)

Translated by Jerrold Landau

  1. Imrei Shoham by Rabbi Moshe the son of Dan Shoham, 5640, 1880.
  2. Maskil El Dal by Rabbi Hillel Lichtenstein, Volume I, third printing, 5640, 1880.
  3. Zichron Sheerit Yosef by Rabbi Yosef of Pozna, 5682, 1882.
  4. Passover Haggadah with the commentary of Damesek Eliezer by Rabbi Eliezer Schwerdscharf, 5683, 1993.
  5. Maase Nisim, about the ten tribes, by Rabbi Moshe Edrei, 5643, 1993.
  6. Avodat Hagershuni by Rabbi Yehuda Gershon Pikholtz, 5683, 1883.
  7. Teivat Gomeh by Rabbi Yosef Teomim, the author of Pri Megadim, 5683, 1883.
  8. Avkat Rochel by Rabbi Hillel Lichtenstein, 5645, 1885.
  9. Or Tzadikim by Rabbi Alter Teicher, 5646, 1886.
  10. Yetziv Pitgam by Rabbi Yaakov Emden, 5646, 1886.
  11. Shem Olam, the book on Moses Montefoire, by Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Gelbard, 5646, 1886.
  12. Maskil el Dal by Rabbi Hillel Lichtenstein, part I, third edition, 5647, 1887.
  13. Shemesh Umagen, a book on the death of Yehoshua Meir Shapira the head of the rabbinical court of Czortkow, by Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Gelbard, 5647, 1887.
  14. Koach Shor, Responsa of Rabbi Yitzchak Schorr, 5648, 1888.
  15. Shulchan Hatahor Hamezukak by Rabbi Yosef Pardo, 5648, 1888.
  16. Mili Dechasiduta by Rabbi Avraham Dov, head of the rabbinical court of Buczacz, 5650, 1890.
  17. Chidushei Hagershuni by Rabbi Yehuda Gershon Pikholtz, 5651, 1891.
  18. Divrei David by Rabbi Avraham David, head of the rabbinical court of Buczacz, 5652, 1892.
  19. Kol Yehuda by Rabbi Yehuda Tzvi Gelbard, 5652, 1892.
  20. Kuntrus 5630 by Rabbi Avraham David, head of the rabbinical court of Buczacz, 5653, 1893.
  21. Zichron Zion or Even Bochen, clarifications of the holy idea of the settlement of the Land of Israel, by Ish Yehudi, 5657, 1897.[1]
[Page 158]
  1. Documents of the Jews of the Four Land of the Kingdom of Poland, by Rabbi Moshe Yaakov Schwerdscharf, 5659, 1899.
  2. Torah Haamim, to bring the nations into the covenant of “fear of G-d”, by Rabbi Moshe Yaakov Schwrdscharf, 5660, 1900.
  3. Proceedings of the Zionist Annotation Office of Galicia and Bukovina in Kolomyya, 5661, 1901.
  4. Tikkun Olam… Anthology of rabbinic enactments in the Four Lands of the Kingdom of Poland by Rabbi Moshe Yaakov Schwerdscharf, 5661, 1901.
  5. Matnat Yehuda by Rabbi Yehuda Gershon Pikholtz, 5662, 1902.
  6. Geulat Yaakov on the commandment of honoring parents by Rabi Yaakov Sofer of Staraginets, 5666, 1906.
  7. Horaat Deah, 5672, 1912
  8. Zichron Larishonim, enactments and customs of the Gemilut Chasadim [charitable organization] of Kolomyya by Rabbi Chaim Tzvi Teomim, 5674, 1914.
  9. The Education of the Jewish Child in the Past and Today, Tarbut School, 5690, 1930.
  10. The “Lulav”, Iton Hatalui, 5691, 1931.

Translator's Footnote:

  1. Ish Yehudi [A Jewish Man] is evidently a pseudonym. Return

[Page 159]

Three Eras

(A little history and memories about Kolomea, my city)

by Yisroel Isser Zeidman (Tel Aviv)

Translated by Gloria Berkenstat Freund

Now, when I describe my home city, my heart fills with longing and my soul becomes full of memories, experiences from my earliest childhood years, of khederim [religious primary schools] and melamdim [teachers in religious schools], dayanim [judges in religious courts] rabbis and rebbes [Hasidic rabbis], of holy Shabbosim [Sabbaths], holidays and the Days of Awe. I spent my best young years in Kolomea, until the year 5674 [1914]. I left the city with our entire household during the bitter month of Av [August], when the First World War broke out and we wandered from place to place and from one country to another. At the end of the war, we returned to Kolomea – and I spent a few beautiful, interesting years there, until 5683 [1923]. That year I left for Eretz-Yisroel. Later, I visited and spent time in my first home twice – in 5689 [1929] and in 5694 [1937].

And today, after a few dozen years, when I want to erect a matzeyvah [headstone] for our dear, beloved city, I must divide its history of the last sixty years before the destruction into three eras, which are in large part characteristic of other cities and shtetlekh [towns] in eastern Galicia: a. the first era before the war – a time of strength and stability; b. the second era begins with the end of the [First] World War; and it extends until the year 5690 (1930) – an era of awakening, of sturmm und drang [storm and distress] in the Jewish neighborhood; an era of great national hope and for a drive for Zion and Eretz-Yisroel; c. and the third era – an era of internal dejection and external heavy stress. In this era we see an evident hint of great misfortune,

[Page 160]

of the catastrophe that would meet the House of Israel in East Europe. In truth, we received signs from above, but we closed our eyes and it was as if we did not notice anything.



During the first era, Kolomea was a quiet, Jewish city. The majority of Jews were Hasidim and only a minority were Zionists and followers of Mizrakhi [religious Zionists]. But during elections or with other communal matters – the Zionists were active and they were the most active element in the life of the city. They were taken into account and discussed. There was also a small minority of assimilated Jews who represented the Jews before the local Polish government. It can be said that the various Hasidic groups were visible in communal life; on the contrary, in important matters the Zionists always emerged on the public level.

The Hasidim prayed in small synagogues that were named after famous rebbes: there was a small synagogue of Kosover Hasidim, Vizhnitzer Hasidim, of Otynier, Ziditshover, Boyaner and Chortkower. And the Hasidic followers would travel to their rebbes, who lived in small shtetlekh [towns], for the Days of Awe and for holidays. It is certainly no coincidence that the great rebbes nonetheless, lived in small shtetlekh. There, their organization was not insignificant as it would be in the bustle of the large city. But in the interwar years, between the two world wars, when Hasidism began to sink, the famous rebbes began to move to the large cities, such as Lemberg and Stanislaw.

And how beautiful and enchanting our Jewish city looked on the eve of a holiday or on the eve of the Days of Awe when the Hasidim and their children – some on foot and others in wagons – with their packs in their hands, went to the train station, to travel to their rebbes, to absorb the holiness, be blessed. Some small synagogues were almost empty during the holidays because only the very simple businessmen remained in the city.

As in the majority of all cities of exile, the Jews of Kolomea also were occupied with commerce and craft, but Kolomea was renowned for the manufacturing of taleysim [prayer shawls]: two large factories produced taleysim – the factories of Yona Zager and of the Hellers. The Heller family

[Page 161]

was an illustrious family. The Hellers were descended from the author of Tosafot Yom-Tov [commentary on the compilation of the oral law named after its author Yom-Tov Lipman Heller] and they were a little haughty. They were Boyaner Hasidim. And after Reb Shimshon Heller died, the business went to his three sons, who were famous scholars, men of good appearance and also versed in worldly matters. Their taleysim were well known in Europe and even in Asia. A traveling, smart and shrewd Jew would travel through all of the Jewish cities and shtetlekh in the old home and would there sell Heller's taleysim, which made famous the Heller firm as well as the city of Kolomea. There were also families that were involved with world trade. They had connections to Germany, Romania and other lands. They were especially involved with the wheat trade. The majority of Jews of the city lived frugally. They were employed in the clothing trade; many were shopkeepers and brokers. Others were artisans and workers. Therefore, even without political pressure, still in the time of the Austro-Hungarians, thousands of Jews from our city took their walking sticks and went west to earn a living. Some of them went as far as Vienna, the capital of Austria; others crossed the border and settled in Germany. (When I was in Leipzig in 1930, I found a small Kolomea synagogue. Our landsleit were employed there mainly with the fur trade.) And many of those from Kolomea immigrated to America to seek employment.

At that time, education in our city was in a rigid and set form: the Hasidim sent their children to khederim of many kinds according to each group's beliefs. In many small synagogues, finding a student of a gymnazie [secular secondary school] was like searching for a bread crumb right before Passover, not to be found. The children received their general education from private teachers – in the afternoon hours or at night. The great mass of people – some of them sent their children to the Jewish school named for Baron Hirsch, and some – to the Polish public school. Only the middle class, assimilated and general Zionists sent their children to the gymnazie. Yet, there were a few families, select ones, whose sons were educated simultaneously in Torah and in general, worldly education. And the sons did not abandon the old way of life. And this was a surprise and a great wonder.

[Page 162]

In spite of the folks-shuln [public school] law, the Hasidic Jews knew how to find a solution: dozens of khederim were overfilled with students of all ages. It was characteristic; the teacher of the youngest children and the teachers of Khumish and Rashi, as well as the teachers who taught the start of the Gemara, were mostly born in Kolomea and they were referred to with their name and occupation: Zalman Melamed and Zayde Melamed. There was also one who was well-known as a pedagogue and he would also teach writing. He also was referred to by his family name: Hersh Rat. However, the well-know Gemara teacher, all the more, the melamdim who taught Gemara and the Rashi commentaries, the melamdim who taught Gemara, commentaries and Tosafos [Talmudic commentaries] were, in general, from other cities and they were called according to their places of origin: Leibish Horodenker, Yosya Buczaczer, Josele Berezaner and Reb Chaim of Rzeszow (he also was a melamed only for adults and even bridegrooms studied with him).

My first teacher, Reb Leibush, lived outside the city, in the fresh air. His house was a poor house, like the poor houses of the poor people and the laborers: a dirt floor and a shingle roof. But, because this was his own house, he was careful with it and gave it his attention. He had a small garden near his house where he planted vegetables: corn, carrots, beans and other vegetables. In general, he had a strong inclination toward trade and employment; he would repair his roof and household objects himself.

Reb Leibush was good at explanations and the students had respect for him. In the afternoon, the kheder was full of children. More students, who in the morning studied at the public school, joined the Hasidic children who studied [in the kheder] in the morning. His son, Shimshon, helped him on Thursdays.

His daughters emigrated to America and he would receive support from his children across the sea during the time between the two World Wars and he lived in comfort.

I started to study Gemara with him. We studied the first chapter of Bava Metzia [Talmudic tractate – The Middle Gate], the chapter, “Shnayim adukin be-tallit' [if two people are holding on to a garment]. And in studying the Mishnah [compilation of Oral Torah] we learned the law: “One shall swear that his share in it is not less than half, and the other shall swear that his share in it is not less than half.” Emphasizing his interpretation and repeating many times – a matter that was written on another side of the Gemara – that it could be that both were swearing the truth: because it was possible, that both

[Page 163]

had lifted the object equally and one did not see the other one. Therefore, each is entitled to half of the bargain. I remember that he would lecture the students that they should live in peace, in friendship and brotherhood. In addition he would bring an example from the animals and birds that live quietly and calmly and help one another. A student once asked him a question:

– Rebbe [teacher]! We still see that the flies – they were a heavy scourge in kheder – attack one another and fight each other.
The rebbe answered authoritatively, “They do not fight with each other, that is how they multiply.”

I moved from Reb Leibush's kheder to Reb Josye Buczaczer. He came to the teaching profession after several transformations: first, he was a merchant in his city of Buczacz [Buchach, Ukraine]. But as he was not successful, his relatives advised him to try his luck in teaching. He then moved to Kolomea and opened a kheder for young men studying Gemara. He was an Otynier Hasid. He was a mixture of a teacher and a pedant. He would explain the vowels of le ekohl-lekhem [“to eat bread.”] (in the Torah portion, Yitro [fifth portion of the Book of Exodus, 18:12], with lots of rules, according to the well-known book, haMaslul [The Path]. His explanation was a good one, but his discipline of the students was weak. He would sometimes permit the good students to spend time outside in the street, as long as they knew the page of Gemara and the Torah portion by the end of the week. When I studied with him, his kheder was near the hill on which we slid during the winter.

Once, I remember I went to talk to my friends and on a winter night I went out with them to slide down the hill. My father, of blessed memory, learned of this. He came to the hill, took me under his arm and led me back into the kheder.

Reb Josele Brotshiner, my teacher for commentary on the Mishnah, commentary on Jewish law and Tosafos, was a melamed of another style (Dr. Shlomo Bikel dedicated beautiful pages to him in his book, A City with Jews). Reb Josele was a remarkable type. He was a great and deep scholar, a distinguished Hasid. He had a strong love for Eretz-Yisroel and tended to reflect on Jewish philosophy. The first term in which I studied with him left a strong impression [that has lasted] until today. We studied the tractate, Nederim [Vows] with Perush haRan [commentary by the RaN, an acronym derived from his name Nissim ben Reuven] (Reb Nissim). While studying we would

[Page 164]

become engrossed in the sugye [Talmud question being studied]. Between the school sessions, he would teach us the eight chapters of Rambam. And thus was the order of instruction in this kheder: from six until eight in the morning – commentary, that is: Yoyre-Deye [second part of the Shulchan Aruch – Code of Jewish Law] or Khoyshn Mishpes [fourth part of the Code of Jewish Law], which we would also refer to as Shach, the [abbreviation of the] name of the commentary Siftei Kohen [Lips of the Kohen written by Rabbi Shabbetai Kohen – referred to as the Shach]. From eight to eight-thirty we would pray together with the rabbi in the small Kaminker synagogue. After praying until 10 o'clock – the students spent time at home for breakfast. From 10 to one – a reading; each would study a page of Gemara alone. And then he repeated it for the rabbi. In the afternoon and during the long winter nights, the teacher would recite a page from the Gemara with Talmudic commentaries and commentaries from rabbinic literature in a very profound manner. On summer nights we would study “posek” [verse of scripture] – Joshua or Job, with commentaries from Meir Leib Weiser. Sometimes he would dictate letters in Hebrew – in the style of flowery language. Thursday in the afternoon we would study the weekly Torah portion and his custom was that he auctioned the sections (Kohan, Levi, shlishi [third] and the like) of the portions among the students – for the benefit of the fund of Reb Meir the miracle worker.

Reb Josele knew to enliven the instruction in that he would let be heard wonderful stories and subjects: once he asked a question: “Who is bigger than the other – The sea or the person?”

– Certainly the sea – the students answered.

– No! – the teacher answered and he explained:

– The size of the sea and its depth has a limit and a foundation: its territory is so much and so much; its depth is so much and so much; however, a person and his soul – who can explore it and fathom it?

He also told us a strange and frightening story: Thus a man was born, grew up, became educated, married and brought children into the world; engaged in business, ran away, was chased and escaped and saw a wonder; in all of his deeds and matters to which a man turns, goes and runs away – an old one runs after him. He sits on the train – the old one with him; he runs away from him across the sea – the old man chases after him; he runs away – and the other one after him; he runs – the old one with him. In short: chasing, running and overtaking until the man fall down exhausted and dead tired and digs him a grave and winks at him: come brother, lie down here, here is your place of rest And Reb Josele Brotshiner, with a luminous smile on his lips, ends

[Page 165]

the story and solves the riddle about the old man: old age – the old one runs after the people.

He would say and repeat for his students: we recognize the man from his walk, from his manner of speaking and from deeds and even from the tip of his pencil.

Of the students who studied with me, Meirtsie Etinger, of blessed memory, should be remembered here. He was a great assiduous student. During the wartime he turned up in Bohemia with his family. He acquired a general education and he passed his exams to enter university. Then he studied oriental scholarship in the University of Prague and received the title of doctor there. He dedicated his few years of life to Hebraic education and was a teacher in the famous Hebrew gymnazie in Muncasz. He remained firm and devoted to Torah and tradition. He visited Eretz-Yisroel twice – with the hope of working in the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. But, in Israel, he suddenly was stricken with severe typhus and he found his last rest on the Mount of Olives (alas, today outside the borders of the Land of Israel).



The day of the outbreak of the First World War, Tisha b'Av [the 9th of Av - a fast day commemorating the destruction of the first and second Temples in Jerusalem] of the year 5674 [1914], left a strong impression on the Jews of our city. I remember when the military was sworn in at the market, an immense group of soldiers stood organized with discipline with the flags and officers and all ready to go to war. On the first day of the war – and an event chases an event: masses of the military were taken – on foot and by train – to the eastern front. And the Jewish population provided large tables with food and drink – on both sides of the highway and near the train – and food and packages were divided generously for all of the soldiers. (It is worth remembering this self-sacrifice of our Jews for the military – which was warmly honored in a collection of letters from Jewish soldiers that was published after war in the capital city of Vienna.)

The first stage of the war turned out bad for

[Page 166]

Austria-Hungary. The Russians crossed the border of Galicia immediately. A storm of Jewish refugees began to move from the border cities, from Czortkow, from Buczacz and from other cities and they came to Stanislaw and Kolomea. But before they could rest, they had to run further. On a Sunday of the first weeks of the war, they began to run from our city, too. But the trains were taken and there were no horses and wagons to be gotten. The rich and wealthy men obtained wagons with great difficulty and for large mounts of money. And thus our family left the city, crowded and pressed together on a simple peasant's wagon and four generations in it: my grandmother Hentsha from Buczacz, who spent the summer months with us, my parents and their children and grandchildren. We dragged ourselves this way to Delatyn and, from there, after we had eaten lunch, we traveled further until we arrived at night in Kereshmeze [Jasina], a small shtetl near the Hungarian border. There, for the first time, we saw the mountain-Jew type who, with his appearance and characteristics, was a product of the Carpathian Mountains.

On a beautiful Friday, my brother and I and several cousin children went out for a stroll in the mountains. We climbed to the mountain top with a hidden feeling of fear and a simultaneous sense of boldness. After we came home, we tasted the kapuste (the cabbage) and the potatoes – really delicious. It was possibly the first time in our lives that we ate with hunger and appetite.

Meanwhile, the Russian occupation expanded. We had to travel further through Hungary – with one stop in the city of Krail – we arrived in Vienna, where we remained until May 1917. From there we traveled to Galanta [Slovakia] in order to be able to study in the famous yeshiva where the Rabbi [Yosef Tzvi] Dushinsky stood at its head. We spent an entire year there. In May 1918 we returned to our city of birth, Kolomea.



That year the Germans as well as Austria-Hungary suffered great military defeats on all fronts; and after, there was a period of political upheaval. The famous 14 Points of the American President Wilson hovered in the air of the wider world. And in the Jewish neighborhood – it was the sweet year of the famous Balfour Declaration. While still in Hungary we heard that a well-known rabbi, a head of a yeshiva had incited and encouraged one of his students, who was a Kohen [priest – descendant of Aaron, the brother of Moses] to learn the Seder Kodashim [the section of the Mishnah – the Oral Law – containing the rules of sacrifice in the Temple in Jerusalem] “because immediately, speedily in our days the Temple would be rebuilt.” Therefore, he had to be ready for his appointment.

There was a great awakening among the Ukrainians for political independence in our area. The Kaiser Karl [Charles I] wanted to bring a remedy for the plague and he proclaimed the liberation of all the people who occupied his land, with the proviso that the Kaiser of the state would be considered as the central figure, who connected all the people of his state, as a unified common political entity. However, it was already too late. After the military suffered defeat on the front, the state crumbled from the inside. And suddenly, over night, a group of small independent nations arose on the ruins of imperial Austria-Hungary, which immediately began to argue and even to fight with one another.

The days of the Ukrainian government in east Galicia were considered as “when a slave reigns.” It was a government of terror for the Jews. Jewish corpses were often brought into the city from the surrounding villages. If one wanted to travel from one place to another, one had to be furnished with official papers and with a particular certificate, with a prepustka [pass] as was said in Ukrainian. And after all of this, one traveled in freight cars. There was a state of war and one was not permitted to go out in the street.

During this terrible time my father, may he rest in peace, came home from Budapest at night. He did not know about the edicts in the city and left for home alone on foot. A Ukrainian patrol detained him on the way. And one said to the other: “Shoot

[Page 168]

him!” My father, may he rest in peace, grabbed him by the arm. He did not lose his courage and said to him: “Come with me to the police. I am an old citizen of the city. They will clarify the matter there.” And thus a miracle happened for him. The Ukrainian patrol obeyed him and went with him. Thus he survived.

During this time, earning a living was more difficult, it was very austere. No commerce could be carried out from one city to another. The Jews began to manufacture things at home. For example: Ersatz coffee was created from certain plants; they fabricated shoe paste [shoe polish], various soaps and similar articles.

The Jewish street was very lively then. Communal life had blossomed during that time. The Balfour Declaration was interpreted as having a literal meaning: a Jewish state. Each group of people organized according to their political faction and leanings. The haHalutz [the pioneer – Jewish youth movement] was founded in Kolomea and various hakshorus [preparatory training for prospective agricultural emigrants to Eretz-Yisroel] in the area of the city. HaShomer [the watchman – Zionist youth group] then developed robust cultural and educational activities. Poale-Zion [workers of Zion – Marxist-Zionist workers movement], Tzeiri Zion [young Zionists], as well as Shomri Tzion [guardians of Zion] (these were the orthodox Jews and the religious young people who yearned for redemption and renewal), also were active and vigorous. And the Bund was very active and the Zionists and the Mizrakhists [religious Zionists] carried out varied activities.

In short, at that time, there was a very stimulating communal spiritual life in all circles: local newspapers were published in Yiddish, many studied Hebrew and there were even groups – particularly from HaShomer – who spoke Hebrew. The assimilated disappeared from view. Many of them became “Jews,” that is, they began to speak Yiddish.

As was said earlier, income was inadequate. We learned an aphorism then: “Income is lacking, let us go study.”

Every night the halls of the parties were full of people who came to various readings and lessons. They studied Khumish [Five Book of Moses – the Torah], Mishnius [commentaries on the Torah], Ein Yakov [Jacob's Well, title of a 16Wednesday, December 18, 2013sacherth century book of rabbinical commentary] and a page of Gemara [Talmudic commentaries]. Every day another party arranged public lectures, gatherings with discussions, literary evenings and even performances.

[Page 169]


Literary Evening

In honor of the grandfather [of Yiddish literature] M[endele] M[Mocher] Sforim [pen
name of Sholem Yankev Abramovich]

[illegible, blurred type]

Shabbos, the 22nd February 1919 (22 Adar 1 [5679])
In the Nuoyzda Hall
Of the Zionist Academic Unions, Avoda [an organization]


Part I:

1) Opening: Mendele - Der Getomohikaner [The Ghetto Mohican – an
    allusion to The Last of the Mohicans – in this case the last ghetto Jew]
  H. Biter

2) Piano solo: Beethoven Sonata in C minor
  Miss Chana Brandes

3) Recitation: Mendele Mocher Sforim play Soloveitchik…
    (with piano accompaniment) . . . H. Kreizler
    At the piano . . . .. . . . . .

Miss Brandes

4) [Talk about trends]: the grandfather and his significance in Yiddish literature
  Mr. Hutshneker
15-minute pause

Part II:

The Martyrs

A dramatic symphony in three acts by Yakov Gordin translated from Hebrew
by Yisroel Biber

The Souls
1. The old Shamas [synagogue sexton] Mr. Gotfrid
2. The merchant Mr. Shafer
3. The melamed [teacher in a religious school] Mr. Paysakh
4. The butcher Mr. Shtampler
5. The student Mr. Kreizler
6. The Girl Miss Krys
7. Ruchl Amnu Miss Sacher

[Page 170]

Yiddish community representation crystallized at the time under the name “Jewish National Council,” in which both active and passive voting rights were given to women. The idea of Eretz-Yisroel and national independence fused. The famous Zionist communal worker, Reb Moshe Laks, of blessed memory, once began to speak in the large synagogue with great inspiration, as if drunk from victories. He began with the famous words from Psalms: “When God will return the captivity of Zion, we will be like dreamers” [Psalm 126:2]. From one thing to the other, he came to the actual question of voting rights for the women. He argued with the audience in the following manner: “It says in the Torah (in the chapter of Berashis [“In the beginning…”]), “v'hu yimshal bakh,” which is usually translated as, “And he will rule over you.” However, we can also translate from fhe word “yimshal,” a moshal [an example], a parallel, and then the translation – v'hu yimshal - “And he will be equal to you.”

At that time, many Jews from the villages and from the smaller cities came to Kolomea and began to occupy a respected place. This development ended with the collapse of the Ukrainian government when the area was occupied first by the Romanians and then by the Poles. The provincial Jew, the agile one, who could climb the stairs of the economic ladder began to push out the old merchant, both in retail [trade] and in wholesale [trade], and even in industry. The Kosower Jews excelled particularly in this regard.

The newly-arrived also had an influence on the communal and cultural life and thus Kolomea became a mother city to the daughters [the shtetlekh]. These sincere young men from the shtetlekh brought fresh blood to the city and provided it with a particular hue. And on the other hand, many from Kolomea traveled to the larger cities and cultural centers of the Jewish world and there they were teachers of Hebrew and other subjects. There were many teachers from our city in Krakow, Munkacs (Czechoslovakia), Lodz and Warsaw. And Dr. Israel Osterzecer had the privilege of being a teacher in the famous Institute of Jewish Studies in Warsaw.

[Page 171]

The enthusiasm of the young faded over the course of years. As long as the political situation in Kolomea district was still not clear, the Jewish population developed educational establishments and cultural institutions that were dedicated to Yiddish and Hebrew. Only after the western states recognized the annexation of east Galicia to Poland did strong assimilation in Poland begin – not as a world view, but as a result of the Jewish life in exile where economic independence did not leave a place for a separate cultural-linguistic existence. Without doubt thousands wanted and strove to go to Eretz-Yisroel, but on one hand there were the bloody events in the country that were repeated often and, on the other hand, there were emigration restrictions; both factors prevented the accomplishment of the aspirations of the masses. This Zionism was a local matter in the kehile [the organized religious community] elections in the lands of exile, representation in the Sejm [Polish parliament], selling Shekels [membership in the Zionist party] and sending delegates to Zionist congresses. Only a small minority of the young chose the long, difficult road of halutszim [Zionist pioneer movement] and hakhshara [agricultural settlements where young Zionists prepared for emigration to Eretz-Yisroel].



The third era stood as a mark of impoverishment and even decline. The Polish government published new edicts every day. True, Eretz-Yisroel was an actual reality; almost every family had relatives in Eretz-Yisroel. But, on the other hand, while they lacked power, there was a great awakening yearning for revolutionary actions, for a mass “clandestine immigration” movement in order to achieve the drive for liberation. And as true idealism was lacking and a certain weakness and indifference ruled on the Jewish streets, an interest began in the ephemeral life and “catch as catch can”– grab and eat. The physical discipline fit like a glove. During my last visit – in 1937 I could see for myself that many synagogues

[Page 172]

were half empty. And the khederim [primary religious schools] – except for the “Foundations of the Torah” [schools] – had almost entirely disappeared. The majority of the young already were receiving a Polish education. They learned Yidishkeit [Jewish way of life] – as in the American way – from private lessons in the afternoon. Divisions even appeared in the fortress of the Shomrei Shabbos [Guardians of the Sabbath]. The excessive practicality and the chase after income left no place for Yidishkeit and for spiritual matters.

Before the outbreak of the Second World War, the social fabric in Kolomea again woke up to a great charitable purpose and for fraternal aid on a very large scale. At that time, hundreds of families were brought to Kolomea from Auschwitz. These were the Jews from Poland and Galicia who had lived in Germany for scores of years, but they did not have German citizenship. And as believable evidence has shown, the entire Kolomea Jewish population was very moved by the fate of the new refugees. They were generously provided with apartments, food and drink, just as the Jewish city had cared about the military that crossed through the city at the outbreak of the First World War.

And even more: as I was told by a believable man, our landsleit [people from the same town] showed great self-sacrifice in saving Jewish souls, even during the time of the Nazi government. At the beginning of the war many Hungarian Jews who had Polish passports were driven to Kolomea. The Nazi government issued a decree and threatened death to everyone in Kolomea who permitted one of the deportees to spend the night. But no one thought about this decree; the Kolomea Jews risked their lives and gave their persecuted brothers a home in which to hide, eat and live.



Ending my memories and impressions of my hometown, Kolomea, I still want to remember a few people who were very close to me and from whom I have written documents. It seems to me that it is worth publishing them on this occasion:

[Page 173]

  1. First, a few fragments from two long letters from my esteemed comrade, Meirtsie Etinger, of blessed memory, who has already been mentioned. The following excerpts are the Yiddish translations from the Hebrew text. The first letter was written Khol Khomoed [intervening days] Passover 5687 [1927], before he came to Eretz-Yisroel.
    “…my heart tells me that although we have chosen different roads in life and that we have parted ways – in truth, it is external. However, internally, in our hearts, we have common aspirations and goals – to discover and to purify the Jewish sparks in us and to bring them back to their source of origin. And on the way we will be able to unite the best of humanity and repair what we have damaged in the course of generations.

    “I will describe for you in subsequent letters my work over the years, since we have not seen each other. It was a time of much energetic work: I studied a great deal and could learn about life not only from books but also as it is: cruel and difficult. When I ended my university studies in Prague, I received a travel stipend to the eastern countries from the university. But the sum did not suffice for the entire trip – and I did not have any other money – I had to postpone the trip for a year and I was compelled to take on a teaching post in the Hebrew gymnazie [secondary school] in Munkacs [previously in Hungary, now Mukachevo, Ukraine]. This is the city famous in all of the lands of exile and I am sure that you have also heard of it. I have been sitting in the sticks for a few months now. True, my work in the school is very fruitful and nice. But I cannot study personally to the degree to which I am accustomed.

    “In the beginning of July I plan to travel to Eretz-Yisroel and I hope to see you there. But in the meantime, I still hope to hear from you details of your life and your deeds.”

    The lines of the second letter are dated the 9th of Chesvan, 5688 [4 November, 1927]. The letter was written after Dr. Etinger had been in Eretz-Yisroel for a short time:
    “I am greatly grieved that I have left Eretz-Yisroel. I cannot describe for you how great my longing is for Jerusalem, for the center of education and elevation of the spirit that one attains there. I now find myself in a city without education, where the Hasidim rule
[Page 174]
    without content. And, although I take part in the important work of laying the basis for a new Hebraic education, and although I have extraordinary success in my work – I do not have any satisfaction in this work because while here I have the influence, the highest authority in all matters, the “fear,” I have a need to be a “student.” The ideal of our people is the “learned man,” “to study” and not to be the teacher. Here I do not have any possibility of continuing my studies; for this reason my decision is to come to Jerusalem after the end of the school year – that means the end of June – and what will be will be.”
  1. An answer from my friend Leibish Heller, may the memory of a righteous man be blessed, to my letter in which I tried to convince him and other friends in Kolomea to come to Eretz-Yisroel and work with me in the Mizrakhi [religious Zionists] teachers' seminary; here in this letter he answered me (also in Hebrew):
    “My dear friend!

    “I have received your first letter from the land. It is difficult to describe the impression and the enthusiasm that I felt while reading; words do not suffice. Praise to God that you had the merit and you have seen the dream of your youth accomplished.

    “About your proposal that a number of our talented friends come there – great yasher koyekh [congratulations]. This is the best evidence that you have not forgotten us. However, I regret very much, my [heartfelt one], to write to you that this 'suffering' over which you have always lamented, increases from day to day. The difficult economic conditions force each of us to help his family in the difficult struggle. For example, our very talented comrade, Sobel – he spends his days and years in his shop on the “canal” in order to help his mother, the widow. Or our friend Menakhmen Sheinfeld, the enthusiastic Hovev Zion [Lover of Zion], who also studied in the Pedagogium [teachers' academy] of the Rabbi, Professor [Zwi Perez] Chajes, of blessed memory in Vienna, sits here in a dark cellar and sells pelts to the gentiles. And if the gentiles stopped coming to him, he has decided to move to a distant village so he can bring them his goods 'to their nose' and so on. This, my friend, is life here. And as I described the proposal to our friend Eliezer Dovid, he groaned bitterly and looked at me with pitiful eyes and stammered: 'Yes, the door is open, but we are bound…'”

[Page 175]

  1. And now a poem from my talented sister, Miriam'tsia, may she rest in peace; she was the youngest daughter and helped a great deal in earning money. This poem, which originally was written in Yiddish, expresses, to a certain extent, the situation of our young people in Kolomea in the years before the outbreak of the Second World War:
    I will my life
    Lament – as consolation,
    That I have given it
    Such wretched spirit.

    I believed that by age
    Twenty and a few –
    I would have [traveled] far
    In the far distance…

    Meanwhile, I have remained standing,
    Here and I cannot go anywhere.
    Although, you scream, although you shout,
    They do not let you go free.

    They need you
    To [share] the suffering of pain,
    To [join in] carrying the yoke,
    You are still needed.


Histadrut haMizrakhi [Mizrakhi organization] in Kolomey, 1929


« Previous Page Table of Contents Next Page »

This material is made available by JewishGen, Inc. and the Yizkor Book Project for the purpose of
fulfilling our mission of disseminating information about the Holocaust and destroyed Jewish communities.
This material may not be copied, sold or bartered without JewishGen, Inc.'s permission. Rights may be reserved by the copyright holder.

JewishGen, Inc. makes no representations regarding the accuracy of the translation. The reader may wish to refer to the original material for verification.
JewishGen is not responsible for inaccuracies or omissions in the original work and cannot rewrite or edit the text to correct inaccuracies and/or omissions.
Our mission is to produce a translation of the original work and we cannot verify the accuracy of statements or alter facts cited.

  Kolomyya, Ukraine     Yizkor Book Project     JewishGen Home Page

Yizkor Book Director, Lance Ackerfeld
This web page created by Lance Ackerfeld

Copyright © 1999-2021 by JewishGen, Inc.
Updated 05 Aug 2021 by JH